PDF copy

A report to the Assistant Treasurer

March 2010

Telephone: (02) 8239 2111
Facsimile: (02) 8239 2100

Australian Government - Inspector-General of Taxation crest

Level 19, 50 Bridge Street
Sydney NSW 2000
GPO Box 551
Sydney NSW 2001

11 March, 2010

Senator the Hon Nick Sherry
Assistant Treasurer
Parliament House

Dear Minister,

On 10 March 2009, the former Assistant Treasurer directed me to review and report on concerns in relation to any perceived ATO delayed or changed approaches — so called 'U-turns' — on significant interpretative matters or on past administrative practices. I am now pleased to provide you with my report on this review which contains my findings as well as recommendations which when implemented should result in significant improvement to tax administration in Australia.

Overall, I found that, in certain circumstances, taxpayers' perception of changes in ATO views or practices are justified. The main problem is not one binding ATO advice clearly changing another, but it is disagreement over whether a previous view or practice existed and if it did exist whether the subsequent view constituted a change. The situation is further compounded by ATO delays in firstly identifying its compliance concerns (which are usually the reasons for developing the subsequent view) and, secondly, finalising its position in relation to those concerns.

Taxpayers are not as concerned with the perceived change as they are with its retrospective effect. To overcome these concerns, I have suggested that the Government consider whether some legislative changes are necessary. In the meantime and in the absence of such legislative change, I have worked with the ATO, with input from business and tax practitioners, to develop mechanisms to reduce the adverse impacts of perceived changed and delayed ATO advice. These mechanisms are contained in recommendations two to five and whilst they may not eliminate the problem, when appropriately implemented, they should improve the level of transparency and due process and thereby significantly alleviate the current concerns.

The direct involvement of key industry representatives, key tax practitioners, the ATO's Acting Second Commissioner - Law, Acting Chief Tax Counsel and particularly the Commissioner of Taxation on key points has greatly enhanced the outcomes of this review. I consider that this direct involvement is a good example of how the ATO, external practitioners, industry and my office can work together to improve Australia's tax administration system.


Ali Noroozi
Inspector-General of Taxation

© Commonwealth of Australia 2010

This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced by any process without prior written permission from the Commonwealth.


David Pengilley, Senior Adviser